After the first tower went dark, the 120 miles between Cape Henry and Cape Hatteras were unmarked for mariners again. There remained a great need for a lighthouse at Bodie Island
to warn mariners to begin a swing away from shore and out to sea to avoid wrecking on Diamond Shoals forty miles south off of Cape Hatteras.
In 1858 the government ordered a second Bodie Island tower to be built of the finest materials available. This time, a secure foundation was laid for the white, eighty-foot-tall tower, and it was fitted with a third-order Fresnel lens. But darker days lay ahead when the lighthouse was destroyed by Confederate armies in 1861, becoming one of the first victims of the Civil War.
After the war, the Light-House Board began repairing war-damaged towers as well as constructing new lights. The site for the present 1870 Bodie Island Light Station was chosen further north, away from the migrating Oregon Inlet.
With the experience of building a successful foundation at Cape Hatteras, Dexter Stetson, superintendent of construction, opted to use the same timber-and-rubble foundation at Bodie Island. Above the wood and granite foundation, nearly one million bricks were laid in a double-wall construction and topped by an iron lantern room. The architectural drawings used at Bodie Island were first drawn for the St. Augustine Lighthouse in Florida, and used again for the Morris Island Lighthouse in South Carolina, the Sand Island Lighthouse in Alabama, and for the Currituck Beach Light as well.
The soul of the lighthouse is its first-order Fresnel lens from Barbier & Fenestre of Paris, France. This magnificent light has served both seagoing vessels as well as local traffic on Pamlico Sound. The lamp inside the lens was lit thirty minutes before sunset and extinguished the following morning thirty minutes after sunrise.
To modernize the lighthouse, the Lighthouse Service installed an incandescent light inside the Fresnel lens that was powered by banks of batteries set in the two workrooms inside the entryway. A flash control motor produced the characteristic flash of 2.5 seconds on, 2.5 off, 2.5 on, and 22.5 seconds off. When the light was electrified in 1932, a 1,000-watt bulb with automatic changer was installed.
In July 2000, the Bodie Island Lighthouse was officially transferred from the U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) to the National Park Service. The lens remained an active aid to navigation and the property of the USCG.
On April 25, 2005, the USCG transferred the title of the first-order Fresnel lens to the National Park Service and the lens is lighted each evening as an active aid to navigation. The tower underwent restoration in 2008; meanwhile, the lens was also restored. Outer Banks Lighthouse Society (OBLHS) volunteers helped with the restoration process. The lighthouse opened to public climbing in 2013 and in October of that year, OBLHS and the NPS hosted a homecoming for Bodie Island keepers' descendants.
The Honorable Senator Marc Basnight requested
state funds to build a new walkway adjacent to and
in back of the lighthouse, which was completed in
summer 2009.
It has become the classic view of this light station.